What is inclusive entrepreneurship

From Wikipreneurship
(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(WHY COPIE'S APPROACH IS SO GREAT)
(WHY COPIE'S APPROACH IS SO GREAT)
Line 71: Line 71:
 
These are:  
 
These are:  
 
1) [[Culture and conditions]]  
 
1) [[Culture and conditions]]  
 +
 
2) [[Integrated Business Support]]  
 
2) [[Integrated Business Support]]  
 +
 
3) [[Appropriate Business Finance]]
 
3) [[Appropriate Business Finance]]
 +
 
4) [[Consolidation and growth]]  
 
4) [[Consolidation and growth]]  
  

Revision as of 17:24, 11 April 2008

BRIEF SELF-INTRODUCTION (to indicate why "I" have been invited, and relation to conference, and topic of this speech)

SIGNPOSTS: WHAT "I" WILL BE TALKING ABOUT: e.g. I am going to give just a brief talk today about what 'inclusive entrepreneurship' is, what it offers society, and why I believe the COPIE approach is so important etc., etc.

(Why am "I" talking about it today. What relation do "I" have with the audience? Why are we talking about this now)

(Why are we talking about inclusive entrepreneurship at this conference? Just refer to this briefly.)


Contents

WHAT IS INCLUSIVE ENTREPRENEURSHIP

What is Inclusive entrepreneurship? Briefly, inclusive entrepreneurship is about widening entrepreneurship opportunity to people from all walks of life. The underlying idea of entrepreneurship that is inclusive is that it should be equally possible for a young mother to set up a new enterprise as it is for a venture capitalist. It should be easy for a new migrant to register their business in the new country (IS THIS THE RIGHT PHRASE? 'The new country'?) It should be possible for anyone with a good business idea to get a loan and get started. Inclusive entrepreneurship is all about making setting up a business possible to all.


Evidence shows that people from any background can be successful in business. Education is no guide to business success (although obviously a bit of education can help). We have seen examples of remarkable transformations where people who had been inactive in the labour market [BECAUSE OF LACK OF EDUCATION?] and who had been sidelined by society have reinvented themselves and gone on to create jobs for others (example here). But as we know there are also problems. (THIS SEEMS A THROWAWAY STATEMENT. PROBLEMS IN RELATION TO WHAT?) (WHY DO YOU BRING IN EDUCATION IN THIS PARA? MORE OF A LINK, AN INDICATION OF WHY YOU CHOOSE TO TALK ABOUT EDUCATION AT THIS POINT NEEDED AT THE BEGINNING.)

[ALSO: ADD STH ON What makes 'inclusive entrepreneurship' inclusive? How is inclusive entrepreneurship different from other entrepreneurship. Is it something a matter of approach/a change of consciousness.... PLUS Is inclusive entrepreneurship sth. that you are bringing into this field of discourse? i.e. is it an invention/a commitment to bring about a particular kind of change by of a particular group of people, or a field of discourse that already exists somewhat independently?)


HISTORY: MY RELATION TO INCLUSIVE ENTREPRENEURSHIP - DIFFICULTIES, ETC. HOW MUCH PROGRESS HAS BEEN MADE

I've been trying to do some of what you are doing for years from inside the European Institutions but not always with much success (IN WHAT CAPACITY HAVE "I" BEEN DOING THIS?)

(SHOULD THIS PARAGRAPH BE GIVEN A LINK IN ITS FIRST SENTENCE TO THE FIRST SECTION IN SOME WAY. FOR INSTANCE, STH ABOUT HOW MUCH HAS BEEN GOING ON IN THIS FIELD IN RECENT YEARS, AND HOW FAR THINGS HAVE COME)


In 1994 we worked with the Merseyside Objective 1 partnership to put a measure into programmes called Pathways to Integration. We wanted people to take an active role in transforming their own run-down communities. We believed then, as I still believe, that every person had the potential to contribute to economic development. One of the lessons we learnt in Merseyside was that entrepreneurship was as important as employment in helping to turn these communities around. This also needed time and investment in building capacity.


Later in the 1990s, I helped the authorities in South Yorkshire to set up the South Yorkshire Key Fund . South Yorkshire had suffered terrible economic restructuring in coal and steel, and the area needed desperately to be turned around. Our original idea was that anyone from the poorest communities could come forward to get support to work up a business idea or a social enterprise, and within two weeks they would either receive the go ahead for their investment or they would get extra help to prepare their idea further. This has now become the Key Fund Yorkshire and supports social and micro entrepreneurs in their communities. I'm convinced that finance plays a major role in helping individuals to set up initiatives.


Back in 2006, Maria Nowak from European Microfinance Network came to see me to ask what Europe could do to promote Microcredit also known as Microfinance. Her organisation ADIE, which she set up nearly 20 years ago, last year lent small sums of money to 18,000 mostly start-up micro enterprises across France. 40% were women and around a third from a migrant background often in the Banlieues. To achieve this, however, she has had to sign nearly 1,000 agreements with municipalities, funding bodies like ERDF and ESF and banks. It shouldn't be so difficult to do the great work that they do.


As a result of her initiative at European level, last autumn the Commission published an initiative on Micro Finance that will provide loan capital and technical assistance to help micro finance institutions with potential to reach more clients and grow rapidly.


So, when we started in this arena in the 1990s there was no way of linking up the actors across Europe. There was no knowledge bank of good practice. No tools that you could use to demonstrate to policy makers that there were parts of their communities that were not being reached. Indeed many policy makers at the time did not believe that there was any entrepreneurial spirit in their poorest communities. Indeed, some may still believe this.


WHY COPIE AND OTHER COMMUNITIES OF PRACTICE [CHECK] ARE SO VERY GOOD

(SEE BELOW. THIS SECTION BELOW IS GOOD. HOWEVER, AT THE MOMENT IT OVERLAPS IN TERMS OF STRUCTURE WITH THE SECTION THAT FOLLOWS IT, WHICH I HAVE CALLED 'WHY COPIE'S APPROACH IS SO GREAT'.)


You, (CHECK - WHO? COPIE?) the people working on entrepreneurship in the Member States, have proved them wrong. Initiatives like the UK's Inner City 100 published annually in the Financial Times were able to show that disadvantaged communities were full of enterprise. Meanwhile projects funded under EQUAL have pushed the envelope to demonstrate that there are techniques for reaching some of the most excluded groups in society and that when you do reach them they can surprise you with their entrepreneurial zeal. I'm hoping that there are people from the Association of Community Based Business Advisers ACBBA in the audience. They have developed a technique of training business advisers from within refugee and migrant community associations. It means that their adviser already speaks Somali or Farsi or Chinese. They have doubled the number of minority ethnic business advisers in London and created the concept of the 'embedded business adviser. Their project reached 1300 clients and is scalable.


We have seen amazing innovation around supporting young people to become entrepreneurs. Who would have thought that Valnalon, a former Objective 2 area in Asturias with a closed steelworks, would be the place where 'minicompanies', one of the most successful school based enterprise programmes, would be developed? Or that the UK's Make your mark campaign where school children had £10 (about €10 at the new exchange rates} to launch an enterprise project in their school. some of the winners had made £400 six weeks later and the ultimate winner did this as a social enterprise where the profit went to African schools.


Inclusive Entrepreneurship sits at the intersection between social policy and economic policy. It is pure Lisbon agenda. We know that economies that have more dynamic entrepreneurial cultures have higher levels of growth. We also know that for many people on the margins of society, entrepreneurship offers more hope of escaping the revolving door of unemployment than going through national schemes. We know that becoming an entrepreneur can be a transformative experience. The danger is that to both the employment and industry ministries, sometimes even the enterprise people think that micro enterprises are too small to register on their radar. It means that they get away with ignoring the contribution that Inclusive entrepreneurship makes. Such ministers are happier meeting the captains of industry. But micro enterprise makes up over 90% of European enterprise and accounts for nearly a third of employment. [CHECK]


WHY COPIE'S APPROACH IS SO GREAT

This is why the COPIE approach of engaging with all of the stakeholders is so crucial for future success. This is why the Declaration on Inclusive Entrepreneurship that is being made today by the Managing Authorities founder members of COPIE is so important.


What COPIE demonstrates is that to make Europe more entrepreneurial and more inclusive requires a range of interventions.


COPIE has broken these down into four elements of an Entrepreneurial ladder: Policy Brief.


These are: 1) Culture and conditions

2) Integrated Business Support

3) Appropriate Business Finance

4) Consolidation and growth


Culture and conditions is about people thinking that this could be for them. It involves, among other things, policy and regulations. We need, for example, to ensure that the regulatory barriers erected in some member states are as low as possible. Where they are high, we find many people going into the informal economy. Good policy prevents this.

Integrated Business support can take many forms, some of the most effective seem to be around coaching and mentoring, as you all know. But the EQUAL experience also shows the value of pre start support [SUCH AS - ONE SPECIFIC EXAMPLE]. Outreach, which I define as getting advisers out of their offices and on to the street is essential. Improving quality both of advisers and support schemes through accreditation is key at this start up stage.

Access to finance (CHECK - Should this be called Appropriate Business Finance) is crucial for all business. we need better financial literacy and capability across the population and especially in potential entrepreneurs. At the start up phase, many entrepreneurs go to family and friends, but this is an area where the banks can do much more especially working with grass roots microfinance organisations. I already mentioned Maria Nowak and the growing band of micro finance practitioners who have taken their lead from Muhammad Yunus in Bangladesh. I also want to emphasise that banks are the most important mainstream source of finance for business. They [CHECK - WHO] may be going through a rough time at the moment; but we must find new ways of dealing with the reason that they are leaving the micro loan business for enterprise. Two reasons are high transaction costs relative to the size of loan and risk. It ought to be possible to find ways of securitising bundles of loans by linking public and private better and by using ERDF and EIB/EIF more creatively.


And finally, with regard to Consolidation and growth, we must do more to ensure these things, for example by looking at how small businesses can get into procurement and commissioning supply chains, and at how marketing can be improved. [JUST A LITTL BIT MORE HERE? INSPIRATION, EXAMPLES etc.]


(ONE EXPLICIT SIGNPOST HERE - I THINK GM IS WORKING TOWARDS A SUMMING-UP, INSPIRING STATEMENT?

"So, I want to end by saying this"; "So what I want to say you is this, and it is in a sense a way of congratulating you, and also underlining how important the work that you do is, and how much more there is left to do ": etc., etc.)

COPIE's [CHECK} community of practice is showing that policy and practice on inclusive entrepreneurship are indivisible. Whereas policy is essentially a top down exercise, practice is from the bottom up. To some degree policy is easy but implementation is hard. You have created a space in which these two groups, policy makers and practitioners, can have a dialogue. You have even brought the voice of the user, the entrepreneur into the room. By working in this way and especially by creating your own knowledge base on Wikipreneurship.eu you will enable to ensure [CHECK - THIS IS AWKWARD] that developments in one part of Europe are known about and understood in another. You aren't the first people to be trying to do this, good work was done on Regional Innovation strategies, around cities through urbact. but you are the first people to focus on Inclusive entrepreneurship.

[INTRODUCE AND THEN PRESENT THIS FINAL JOKE IN A BETTER WAY, TUCK THE WEST WING REFERENCE IN FIRST, IN A LITTLE ASIDE - MAKE PEOPLE CHUCKLE BUT THEN MAKE THEM FEEL GOOD ABOUT THEMSELVES]

“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.”Margaret Mead, the anthropologist

this was also popularised by President Bartlett in the TV series West Wing

notes and references

[http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/employment_strategy/index_en.htm Joint Employment Report 2007/2008


[1] found nothing

Joint Employment Report 2006/2007

inclusive entrepreneurship actions page 11 1st and 2nd para, p 13, 2nd para


[http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/employment_strategy/guidelines_en.htm inclusive entrepreneurship employment guidelines] GL 15

last report with recommendations

annual progress report on growth and jobs 10 countries have reported actions on start ups or entrepreneurship

on DG Regio website [2]


the Community strategic guidelines on cohesion

entrepreneurship 1.2.2 last para, end of 1.2.4 last item in box, 1.2.4 3rd last bullet pointInclusive entrepreneurship is about widening entrepreneurship opportunity to people from all walks of life. Its underlying idea is that it should be equally possible for a young mother to set up a new enterprise as it is for a venture capitalist. It should be easy for a new migrant to register their business in the new country. It should be possible for anyone with a good business idea to get a loan and to get started.

Evidence shows that people from any background can be successful in business. Education is no guide to business success (although a bit can help). We have seen examples of remarkable transformations where people who had been inactive in the labour market and who had been sidelined by society have reinvented themselves and gone on to create jobs for others (example here). But as we know there are also problems.


I've been trying to do what you are doing for years but not always with as much success. In 1994 we worked with the Merseyside Objective 1 partnership to put a measure into programmes called Pathways to Integration. We wanted people to take an active role in transforming their own run down communities. We believed that every person had the potential to contribute to economic development. One of the lessons we learnt in Merseyside was that entrepreneurship was as important as employment in helping to turn these communities around.

Later in the 1990s, I helped the authorities in South Yorkshire to set up the South Yorkshire Key Fund . South Yorkshire had suffered terrible economic restructuring in coal and steel. Our original idea was that anyone from the poorest communities could come forward to get support to work up a business idea or a social enterprise, and within two weeks they would either receive the go ahead for their investment or they would get extra help to prepare their idea further. This has now become the Key Fund Yorkshire and supports social and micro entrepreneurs in their communities. I'm convinced that finance plays a major role in helping indivduals to set up initiaves.

Back in 2006, Maria Nowak from European Microfinance Network came to see me to ask what Europe could do to promote Microcredit or Microfinance. Her organisation ADIE, which she set up nearly 20 years ago, last year lent small sums of money to 18,000 mostly start-up micro enterprises across France. To achieve this, however, she has had to sign nearly 1,000 agreements with municipalities, funding bodies like ERDF and ESF and banks. It shouldn't be so difficult to do the great work that they do.

As a result of her initiatve at European level, last autumn the Commission published an initiative on Micro Finance that will provide loan capital and technical assistance to help micro finance institutions with potential to reach more clients and grow rapidly.

When we started in this arena in the 1990s there was no way of linking up the actors across Europe. There was no knowledge bank of good practice. No tools that you could use to demonstrate to policy makers that there were parts of their communities that were not being reached. Indeed many policy makers at the time did not believe that there was any entrepreneurial spirit in their poorest communities. Some may still believe this.

You have proved them wrong. Initiatives like the UK's Inner City 100 published annually in the Financial Times were able to show that disadvantaged communities were full of enterprise. Meanwhile projects funded under EQUAL have pushed the envelope to demonstrate that there are techniques for reaching some of the most excluded groups in society and that when you do reach them they can surprise you with their entrepreneurial zeal. I know that there are people from the Association of Community Based Business Advisers ACBBA in the audience. They have developed a technique of training business advisers from within refugee and migrant community associations. It means that their adviser already speaks Somali or Farsi or Chinese. They have doubled the number of minority ethnic business advisers in London and created the concept of the 'embedded business adviser. Their project reached 1300 clients and is scalable.

We have seen amazing innovation around supporting young people to become entrepreneurs. Who would have thought that Valnalon, a former Objective 2 area in Asturias with a closed steelworks, would be the place where 'minicompanies' - one of the most successful school based enterprise programmes, would be developed?

Inclusive Entrepreneurship sits at the intersection between social policy and economic policy. It is pure [[Lisbon agenda]. We know that economies that have more dynamic entrepreneurial cultures have higher levels of growth. We also know that for many people on the margins of society entrepreneurship offers more hope of escaping the revolving door of unemployment than going through national schemes. We know that becoming an entrepreneur can be a transformative experience. The danger is that to both the employment and industry or enterprise ministries [CHECK] micro enterprises are too small to register on the radar. Such ministries are happier meeting the captains of industry. But micro enterprise makes up over 90% of European enterprise and accounts for nearly a third of employment. [check]

This is why the COPIE approach of engaging with all of the stakeholders is so important for future success. this is why the Declaration on Inclusive Entrepreneurship that is being made today by the Managing Authorities founder members of COPIE is so important.

What COPIE demonstrates is that to make Europe more entrepreneurial and more inclusive requires a range of interventions

COPIE has broken these down into four elements of an entrepreneurial ladder the culture and conditions is about people thinking that this could be for them. We also need to ensure that the regulatory barriers erected in some member states are as low as possible. Where they are high we find many people going into the informal economy. Good policy prevents this. Start up support can take many forms, some of the most effective seem to be around coaching and mentoring, but the EQUAL experience also shows the value of pre start support. Quality is key at this stage [[access to finance] is crucial for all business, at the start up phase many entrepreneurs go to family and friends, this is an area where the banks can do much more especially working with grass roots microfinance organisations Finally we must do more to ensure consolidations and growth for example by looking at how small businesses can get into procurement and commissioning supply chains, and at how marketing can be improved,

Policy and practice

Your community of practice is showing that policy and practice on inclusive entrepreneurship are indivisible. Whereas policy is essentially a top down exercise, practice is from the bottom up. To some degree policy is easy but implementation is hard. You have created a space in which these two groups: policy makers and practitioners can have a dialogue. You have even brought the voice of the user, the entrepreneur into the room. By working in this way and especially by creating your own knowledge base on Wikipreneurship.eu you will enable to ensure [CHECK] that developments in one part of Europe are known about and understood in another. You aren't the first people to be trying to do this, good work was done on Regional Innovation strategies, around cities through urbact. but you are the first people to focus on Inclusive entrepreneurship


“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has.”Margaret Mead, the anthropologist

this was also popularised by President Bartlett in the TV series West Wing


notes and references

[http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/employment_strategy/index_en.htm Joint Employment Report 2007/2008


[3] found nothing

Joint Employment Report 2006/2007

inclusive entrepreneurship actions page 11 1st and 2nd para, p 13, 2nd para


[http://ec.europa.eu/employment_social/employment_strategy/guidelines_en.htm inclusive entrepreneurship employment guidelines] GL 15

last report with recommendations

annual progress report on growth and jobs 10 countries have reported actions on start ups or entrepreneurship

on DG Regio website [4]


the Community strategic guidelines on cohesion

entrepreneurship 1.2.2 last para, end of 1.2.4 last item in box, 1.2.4 3rd last bullet point